Silly myths about starting a jewelry side hustle

RELATED READS

The best platforms to sell handmade jewelry
14 little bits of magic to make your jewelry brand shine
Why every jewelry collection needs evergreen pieces
Finding the RIGHT jewelry suppliers

Let’s get all those silly misconceptions that are knocking around on the internet out the way, then you can really start thinking about your huge dream…your jewelry making side hustle that will give you the freedom you really want. Wow! 🤗

Myth 1: You need lots of money to start a Jewelry business

Ahhh the classic dream crusher…

But really – no! – Unless you’re planning on starting the next Cartier?
Most jewelry businesses start on the kitchen table. You can begin with a small set of tools, a handful of beads or silver, and an itch – just slowly start creating a gorgeous collection. If you are after starting a jewelry brand and want to curate a collection and need inventory OR you want to design and find a manufacturer to produce a collection – you may need to sell a kidney, but a maker…you’re golden.
I make to order, so when an order comes in, I make it! I carry enough stock to get me through a week or two at the most, I buy small and often.

Myth 2: So many people are selling jewelry, it’s too crowded

You’re right – it is crowded 😮.

But so is the coffee industry, and that didn’t stop people queueing round the block for a Starbucks.
Saturation only matters when you have nothing that makes you you. People don’t just buy handmade jewelry – they buy stories, meaning, connection. Your wanderer-inspired bracelet or baby-birthstone charm carries heart that factory pieces never will.

Crowded markets aren’t a warning sign, they’re proof there’s demand.
You just need to carve out your little corner and make it sparkle! ✨

Myth 3: I won’t make enough money selling handmade jewelry

Maybe not straight away – but that’s true for almost every business, not just jewelry, right?

If you really zero in on your customer, like obsessively – you’ll get there faster.
Understand what they want, what they worry about, and why they buy. Listen harder than anyone else. Then meet their expectations… and quietly overdeliver.

The jewelry industry is worth over $300 billion worldwide, so plenty of sparkle to go around.
Go claim your corner of it!

I started small, spare room start up…
Now it’s a six-figure jewelry business run by… well, just little-ol me!

Myth 4: I need formal training to succeed

No, no, no, no, no. next question.
(Actually, just a small afterthought, always keep refining, never stop learning, there’s so much great content out there online to learn jewelry making – you don’t need a university degree, just creative passion and curiosity, I never trained in jewelry making).

Myth 5: I’ll have tons of free time if I’m my own boss

No way José.
…What you’ll actually find is… you’ll have less free time. Sorry!
You become the maker, the marketer, the photographer, the accountant the packer.

But when it’s your business, and it lights you up, it so doesn’t feel like work. You’ll catch yourself designing at midnight, grinning like a maniac because you’ve designed a new pretty bracelet.

Yes, you’ll wear all the hats – but they’re your hats 🎩

Myth 6: I’m terrible with numbers – I’ll mess up pricing

I think I got an F in maths… does it even go that far before it counts as a nothing?

Turns out you just need a calculator, some super smart software, and a decent accountant.

Myth 7: My family/friends won’t take it seriously

They probably won’t – at least, not at first 😬
You’ll get the polite smiles, the “Oh, that’s nice dear”, and the occasional “So when are you getting a real job?” – (love that one!)

But, they don’t have your vision. They can’t see what you’re building, and that’s okay. You’re not doing it for anyone’s approval, you’re doing it to build your freedom.

When the orders start rolling in and you’re shipping from the kitchen table with a grin, those same people will suddenly want to know how you did it.

So keep going. Let your progress do the explaining.

Myth 8: I’m too old to start a business now

Wow…now that’s just plain silly!

Business is not just for young-uns – no one should ever utter ‘I’m too old to’…it’s not aloud on here! 😉

Myth 9: I’ll look silly if it’s just a small Etsy shop

Ah…And I thought size didn’t matter! 🤭

If I were starting a jewelry business in 2025, I’d absolutely begin on Etsy (checkout my best platform’s for handmade jewelry blog post here to learn more). It’s one of the few places where your shop sits right in the middle of constant foot fall, like you’ve opened up on Carnaby Street. People are already there browsing, buying, and searching for exactly what you sell.

Start with your own branded website instead and you’re basically pitching from a mountain in Alaska – beautiful, but no one can find you. You’ll need to learn Meta ads, Google ads, email funnels (got that covered too 🤗), SEO, and probably a bit of magic before anyone even sees your first product.

Etsy gives you visibility while you learn the ropes, it’s an amazing starting point. Grow your skills, refine your brand – expand when you’re ready to something that feels ‘bigger’.

Who knows? That ‘small’ Etsy shop might surprise you and end up earning you more profit than you think.

Myth 10: I’m not good at social media – so I’ll never get seen

Good news: you don’t need to be an a social butterfly to sell jewelry.
No ring lights, dances, or “Hey guys!” intros required.

I can’t believe I’m going to admit this out loud…
For my own jewelry store www.OhSoCherished.co.uk, I barely touch social media 😬.
There…I’ve said it.

So if you hate social media. That’s okay. There are other ways to be seen – Pinterest, Email Marketing, Blogging, SEO, Marketplaces, Physical Stores – what you need is slow, steady traffic that keeps working even while you sleep.

There’s a lot of crazy advice swirling around the online business world. Some of it’s helpful. Some of it? Not so much.

Before you go, remember this:

Size doesn’t matter!
You can learn every skill you need from home
Being social is optional
We don’t care about age here!
Freedom doesn’t happen by accident

At the end of the day, your business doesn’t have to look like anyone else’s.
You get to build it exactly the way that works for YOU.

💕 If this post fired you up to start your side hustle, you might like Why I Started My Jewelry Business (and Why I’m Still Doing It) – a little story about passion & freedom. Or first learn… The things no one really tells you about being a jewelry maker.